9 Best Restaurants in Cedarburg

9 Best Restaurants in Cedarburg

  • Jaime Lubner Group
  • 04/30/24

Cedarburg, WI isn’t just a charming historic town with cobblestone streets; it’s also a haven for food enthusiasts. The culinary scene here is an exciting mix of local flavors, artisanal creations, and international cuisine. Read on for a flavorful journey through some of the best restaurants in Cedarburg, where every meal is a celebration of taste and tradition.

Anvil Pub & Grille

Location:  N70 W6340 Bridge Rd, Cedarburg, WI 53012

Begin your culinary adventures at Anvil Pub & Grille, a perfect blend of a traditional pub with a modern twist. The ambiance (a former blacksmith shop) is cozy, and the menu is a fusion of classic pub fare and inventive, contemporary dishes. From their signature burgers to the flavorful iron pesto pasta or Avril mac ‘n cheese, every bite is comfort food at its finest.

The Stilt House Gastro Bar

Location: W62 N630 Washington Ave, Cedarburg, WI 53012

Prepare for an extraordinary dining experience at The Stilt House, a restaurant known for its innovative culinary creations and a warm, welcoming atmosphere. Offering a farm-to-table approach, their menu boasts an array of seasonal dishes that highlight locally sourced ingredients. Don’t miss their delectable firecracker shrimp with pineapple salsa, wild mushroom flatbread with balsamic glaze, carne asada tacos, or the ever-popular Wisconsin cheese curds.

Cream & Crepe Café

Location: N70 W6340 Bridge Rd, Cedarburg, WI 53012

Craving something sweet or savory? Cream & Crepe Café, next door to Anvil Pub & Grille, is the go-to spot for a delightful array of both. Known for its mouthwatering crepes, this charming café entices patrons with an inviting atmosphere and a diverse menu. From the Nutella-stuffed crepes to the savory ham and cheese combinations, every bite is a heavenly experience.

The Farmstead

Location: W62 N238 Washington Ave, Cedarburg, WI 53012

For an authentic farm-to-table dining experience, The Farmstead stands as a pioneer. This beloved steakhouse, housed in a rustic 150-year-old fieldstone farmhouse, takes pride in using fresh ingredients sourced from local farms, resulting in a menu that reflects the true essence of Cedarburg. The Farmstead’s seasonal dishes and ever-evolving menu make every visit a culinary adventure, and their Sunday brunch is a must-try.


Location: W63 N688 Washington Ave, Cedarburg, WI 53012

Indulge in authentic Italian cuisine at Tomaso's, a family-owned restaurant that’s a local favorite. With a cozy, casual atmosphere and a menu boasting classic Italian dishes, this eatery offers a culinary journey that transports you straight to the heart of Italy. From their flavorful pasta dishes to their savory pizzas, every meal embraces Italian culinary traditions.

Java House

Location: W63 N653 Washington Ave, Cedarburg, WI 53012

Begin your day at Java House, a cozy café that's more than just a coffee stop. Offering a variety of breakfast and lunch options since its inception in 1992, Java House is well-known for its warm atmosphere and a menu filled with delightful surprises, from the cafe au lait and hot chocolate to the peanut butter mocha, butterfly tea lemonade, and fresh fruit smoothies. Don’t miss their avocado toast or their classic breakfast sandwich to kickstart your day.

Hefner’s Frozen Custard & Jumbo Burgers

Location: N71 W5184 Columbia Rd, Cedarburg, WI 53012

Hefner’s Frozen Custard & Jumbo Burgers is more than just your average burger joint. Indulge in their jumbo-sized, flavorful burgers paired perfectly with their creamy, decadent frozen custard. Whether it's a classic burger or a specialty custard flavor like the caramel brownie or cashew creation, every visit here is a wonderful experience.

The Chocolate Factory

Location: W62 N577 Washington Ave, Cedarburg, WI 53012

Satisfy your sweet tooth cravings after your meal at The Chocolate Factory. Enjoy classic subs and croissant sandwiches with freshly baked breads. Then Indulge in Wisconsin-made ice cream, root beer floats, and delectable ice cream sundaes and shakes. It’s your one-stop shop for everything delightful.

Ready to move to Cedarburg?

If you’re intrigued by these fantastic restaurants in Cedarburg, expert local agent Jaime Lubner of the Jaime Lubner Group can help you make your move to the area. Working with Jaime, you can expect nothing short of excellence and a focus on your goals at every point. Connect with the team today to get started in finding your dream home.

Connect With Us

Whether you’re ready to buy or sell or are considering a move at some time in the future, we’d love to talk with you today.

Follow Us on Instagram